Britain's first book blogger (November 2000)

Wednesday, November 29, 2006

Zombies and consciousness

From Philip Goff's TLS review of Robert Kirk's new book.
A philosophical zombie, as opposed to its undead namesake, is an atom-for-atom physical duplicate of a human being ... which lacks any kind of conscious experience. If you put a knife in it, it will scream and try to escape. If you give it a cup of tea, it will thanks you politely and sip it with a smile. It can do your job and chat to your colleagues as cleverly or as ineptly as you yourself can. And yet there is nothing that it is like to be your zombie twin. Its screams are not accompanied by the feeling of pain. Its tea drinking is not accompanied by the taste of tea, or the feeling of warmth and pleasure. It does not have any sensory experience of the three-dimensional world with which it interacts so well. The lights are on but nobody is at home.

Nobody thinks zombies are real, but some philosophers - a sizeable minority - think that zombies are possible.
Yes, I've also been to one too many philosophy seminars.

1 comment:

  1. Anonymous10:54 pm

    I was thinking about this same topic. My question is, Is consciousness a natural result of having a sufficiently complex brain?

    A zombie will, as pure behaviour, attempt to solve problems, creating a model of its world. Because the zombie itself is a factor in its world, its model will include a model of its own mind.

    Is this what it means to be conscious?

    ReplyDelete

Contact

Please email me at steve dot mitchelmore at gmail dot com.

Blog Archive

Followers

Contact steve dot mitchelmore at gmail.com. Powered by Blogger.